Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many)

oh, the reason a head or brain transplant is just not viable is that the brain isn't really an isolated organ, the spinal chord is an extension of it, or equivalently, the brain is an extension of the spinal chord. they're even made of the same stuff? i had no idea

1 replies →
1 replies

Saagar Jha

(replying to Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many))
@hikari Ok but like I feel that most people’s consciousness is not even housed in the entirety of the brain but just a part of it. And that’s typically what people want to keep

Saagar Jha

(replying to Saagar Jha)
@hikari Like ok yes this body is miserable it feels too cold and I don’t know how to make it breathe but I would think if you transplanted my frontal cortex it would be I who thought that and not some weird half consciousness version of me

Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many)

(replying to Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many))

this is why they talk about the “central nervous system”, the brain is just the big blobby bit of it at the top

so, to transplant a brain or head would be at least as complicated as stitching two brains together. great. never gonna happen

Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many)

(replying to Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many))

this prompts the obvious idea of “why don't you transplant the entire cns then” and i am very satisfied by the fact that i came to that conclusion before it came up in the video i was watching (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4hFRfOeZX8)

of course that's not easy either :p

Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many)

(replying to Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many))

in this house we reject the mind–body dualism

✧✦Catherine✦✧

(replying to Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many))

@hikari you can transplant a person (a person is a type of fire, one is not inherently tied to a chunk of meat) but this requires a very flexible sense of self and being ready to experience profound loss

not exactly the traits of people who dream of head transplants

Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many)

(replying to ✧✦Catherine✦✧)

@whitequark brutal

✧✦Catherine✦✧

(replying to Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many))

@hikari am i wrong?

Iwasawa 🌟 (one hikari of too many)

(replying to ✧✦Catherine✦✧)

@whitequark no, the problem is you're completely correct